8 Gorgeous Cushion Cut Engagement Rings Under $5000

This article may contain links that help us earn a commission when you make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you.

Looking for a timeless yet stunning style for an engagement ring? Look no further than the cushion cut diamond. This romantic and gorgeous design is perfect for you and your loved one without being overly flashy. Plus with our carefully curated list of 8 gorgeous cushion cut engagement rings under $5000, your bank account might thank us!

Related: Best Engagement Rings for Couples on a Budget – Under $5000

Table of Contents
8 Gorgeous Cushion Cut Engagement Rings Under $5k
What Makes Cushion Cut Diamond Rings So Popular?
Where To Buy Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Rings
Tips For Buying Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Rings Under $5k
Final Thoughts

8 Gorgeous Cushion Cut Engagement Rings Under 5k

1. The Original Solitaire Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

The Original Solitaire Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

This stunning diamond ring with a solitaire setting from James Allen is our personal favorite. This engagement ring features a 14k white gold metal band and four beautiful prongs to complement the center diamond. Swapping the 14k white gold setting out for an 18k yellow gold would also look amazing. With their signature Comfort Fit band and affordable price tag, we can see why this ring has over 1000 five star ratings. (Click here to view)

Related: 7 Solitaire Engagement Rings To Make Her Fall In Love

2. The Melina

The Melina

This beautiful engagement ring from Clean Origin is both environmentally-friendly and unique. The ring is gracefully accented with delicate pave diamonds and highlights the beauty of the gorgeous center stone. With its 18k white gold setting, the Melina is a popular choice for cushion cut diamond lovers. (Click here to view)

3. The Channel-Set Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

The Channel-Set Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

They say the best diamond rings don’t exist. We beg to differ. This 1.31 carat channel-set ring from James Allen carries both a brilliant VVS2 clarity grade and affordable price tag. It’s typically quite rare to find diamonds over one carat mark for under $5000. So it goes without saying that this cushion cut ring from James Allen is an absolute steal. (Click here to view)

4. The Side Stone Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

The Side Stone Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

At 1.34 carats, this side stone cushion cut diamond ring from James Allen might be the perfect engagement ring for you and your loved one. This ring features a round diamond accent along the sides of the ring, creating a pathway upto the beautiful center stone as the main attraction. (Click here to view)

5. The Three Stone Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

The Three Stone Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

What’s better than one stone? That’s right – three stones! This ring features unique diamond shapes with a center cushion cut diamond and baguette diamonds on the side. In fact, finding baguette diamonds on engagement rings under $5,000 is actually quite rare because of their quality craftsmanship. (Click here to view)

6. The Leslie Ring

The Leslie Ring

This unique ring from Clean Origin is a blend of a three-stone ring and a vintage ring featuring a cushion cut center stone. Beautiful engagement rings are normally hard to come by, but this Leslie ring from Clean Origin is the perfect ring for couples looking for something unique with smaller diamonds on the sides. (Click here to view)

7. The Halo Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

The Halo Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

Halo engagement rings are all the rage these days. They feature a singular center stone with multiple round diamonds surrounding the center. A diamond halo ring is flashy, bold, and certain to turn heads. Halo rings aren’t for everyone but if that’s your style, this 1.22 carat diamond ring from James Allen will be the perfect ring for you. (Click here to view)

Related: 5 Beautiful Halo Engagement Rings She’ll Say Yes To

8. The Vintage Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

The Vintage Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

We absolutely love this rare, vintage design on this cushion cut ring from James Allen. Not only is the ‘infinity’ 14k yellow gold setting unique, we’re genuinely impressed with how well the 1.01 carat VS2 diamond pairs with the yellow gold setting. Our only wish is that the infinity design had some diamonds along the setting. But when this vintage ring is less than $4000, it’s hard to complain. (Click here to view)

Cushion cut diamond rings have been a popular choice for brides for many years due to their unique look. Cushion cut diamonds are known for their rounded corners, cushion or pillow-like appearance, and 56 facets (the flat, geometrical pattern on the face of the diamond).

cushion cut diamond

Related: Are Tiffany Engagement Rings Worth It?

This type of cut is perfect for brides looking for the charm of a square or rectangle-cut diamond without the sharp edges, which makes the cushion cut both beautiful and practical.

The cushion cut diamond is also very popular because its unique shape gives the illusion of a larger diamond, making it perfect for couples looking to make the most of the carat weight for their diamond while keeping costs down.

As an added bonus, cushion cut diamond rings are very versatile and look amazing in nearly any type of metal setting. Whether you choose to go with rose gold, yellow gold, white gold, or platinum, a cushion cut center stone will pair perfectly with your engagement ring settings.

Where To Buy Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Rings

Buying an engagement ring is a big deal, so you want to make sure you’re getting the most value from your purchase.

If you’re in the market for a high quality cushion cut diamond engagement ring, James Allen and Clean Origin are amongst the best places to buy them.

james allen homepage

Both retailers offer a wide selection of stunning and affordable engagement rings with different sizes, carat weight, settings, and more, making it the perfect one-stop-shop for all your diamond engagement ring needs.

Related: James Allen vs Clean Origin: Head-to-Head Comparison

To take it a step further, both sites offer free shipping in the United States and Canada, making it easier and convenient for you to get your gorgeous engagement ring quickly no matter where you live in the country.

Tips For Buying Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Rings Under 5K

  • Find GIA or IGI certified diamonds

  • Understand the 4 C’s (cut, clarity, color, carat)

  • Look for eye-clean diamonds

Find GIA or IGI certified diamonds

When shopping for cushion cut diamond engagement rings, it’s important to find diamonds certified by GIA or IGI. This certification will include detailed information about your diamond such as diamond size, shape, quality, and more.

This is important because you want to ensure you’re buying your diamonds at a fair price with the appropriate qualities and characteristics. Having a diamond GIA or IGI certified by a professional gemologist will ensure you’re always paying the right price for your diamonds.

Understand the 4 C’s (cut, clarity, color, carat)

We recommend taking the time to learn about the cut, clarity, color, and carat of the diamond as these factors can largely affect the price.

clarity grade

Fortunately, you can check out in-depth guide here on what are the 4 C’s and why they’re so important.

Look for eye-clean diamonds

If you’re on a budget, we wouldn’t recommended getting worried over the exact specifications of a diamond’s clarity or color grade.

Instead, we recommend finding diamonds that are near-perfect or eye-clean. This means finding diamonds that have no visible flaws, blemishes, or inclusions to the naked eye, despite what the official clarity and color grades are.

near perfect diamonds

These grading scales are made with a microscope and equipment that are much more capable than the human eye. So don’t get too worried if your diamond doesn’t have a high clarity or color grade. As long as it looks eye catching and clean, you’ll be far better off especially if you’re on a budget.

Final Thoughts

To wrap it all up, cushion cut diamonds are a great alternative to square or rectangle cuts if you’re looking to have a similar style but don’t want the sharp edges. Not only are they more affordable than most round diamonds, they also shine and sparkle brighter than them with their 56 facets!

If you enjoyed this post, consider subscribing to our newsletter for more advice, tips, and tricks directly to your inbox.

Photo of author
John Anderson
With over two decades of wedding experience, John Anderson is the Co-Founder and Executive Editor at Life Line Wedding. He writes a variety of articles spanning over multiple areas of expertise including engagement rings, diamonds, wedding jewelry, and wedding planning. John's mission is to help soon-to-be-married couples make educated and well-informed decisions. He now spends his time writing articles to help couples on Lifelinewedding.com. John is based in Brooklyn, NY.